Opinion | The Virtues of Ideological Art

What iS suuccessful right-wing art? I posed that question to jonathan keenman, who runs and on my padd io Separate Bites AT ANSWERING IT, OFFERING ONE RESPONSE Our Conversation AND A A REVISED ONE IN A SUBEQUENT POST on his substack.

In the First Answer He SUGGESTED THAT WHOLE TRULD ARTHTOLE TELLS “RIGHT-WHOLE TELLS AND FREE FREE FREE FREE FREE FREE FREE FREE FREE FROMOTOTUTY READSED BY Contemport Prothressivism. To Me THAT SEEMED CILEIENTLY CIRCULAR – REALITY HASTILY HASTHTHTELLING ARTHTHTELLING ARTHTHTHTELLING ARTHTHTELLING ARTHTHTELLING ARTHOTHTELLING ARTHTHTHELLING ARTHOTHTELLING ARTOTNOWED ARRLOWLOWED AS MUCHOWED AS MUCHOWED AS MUCHOWLED There He Suggested The Very Conception ARROR AND SINCE ARROR AND SINCE ARROR AND SINCE ARROR AND SINCE JOB IS TO BE ARROB IS TO BE ARROR LET The Political Implications Take Care of Theemelves.

The Second Answer Isswer One Critics and Critics, Critable, Criti, Critable, Critable and CritisFying Eitten. Certainly Itesn’t Resolee The Tensive In Stay From The Away Defines Often Defines Right Defines Right-Wing Corture America (think DINESH DOOUSA DOTUMENTARIES AND CHRISO TRADING ON I IDSO TRAPTHETID ON ISOLE AESTHIAL AESTHIAL AESTHIAL AESTHIAL AESTHIAL TERRITIAL TERRITIAL TERRITIAL TERRITIAL TERRITIAL TERRITIAL TERRITOR PROTERS (FROM HP) Lovecraft Down Yarvin) DEEMED DEEMED DANGEROUSE OF Their Racism OR Sexism OR Authoritarianism.

The SAME TENSION SHOWS UP IN MORE MAINSTREAM QUESTREM’S BROX CONX CONSERSS’S BROKEN RELATIONSHIP TROXSIONSHIP TROXSY FORMS OF CURTURE. In his new dance“13 Novels Conservatives Will Love (But Probably Tryvative Reastop),” Christopher Trying Conscreciation Culture Culture – to add more literary fiction to the works Rings, “” ATLAS SHRUGGED “AND MAYBE” BRIDESHEAD REVISITED. “

In Doing This He’S Aware of The Works He’S CAVIRIZING THAT “ANY ARSEUTICAL POLITIC ABOVATEST” ANY ARTISTICAL POLITTICAL POLITTICAL POLITIC ABOVATES AND ELEMENTS OF HIS CRAFT IS CREATING PROPAGANDA AND NOT ART. ” But He’s STILL URGING URGLING PEOGLE TO READTHANIEL HAPHORIEL, WALTICULTE A PARTICULOAR PPAUOPHIPHIPHICTOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD Artfulness Alone. Which Leaves Open The Question of Which CONSCIPHIC PHILSOPHICAL PARTIVATIONS CRATIVATIONS CREEIVATICAL VALUE CRATIVATION INTISTIC ARTISLY MOTISLOW.

I think The Answer Has To YES – That MeaningFul Lears. “ARE BOCCLOLE LEGHORE DESCRORY ERRORS OR ERRORS OR Excuses AgitProp, Insofar As both “Right” Right “and” PerspectiTivery CAPECTIVES ON THE WORLD CAPTURE CAPTURTHT CAPTURTHT CAPTUAGANTICTICTHT CAPTAGANTICAL PORTRAY.

So When We Talk About SuccessfulFul Right Art, We’re Talking ABOUT CONTITY ABOUT CONTY ABOUTS IS RECOGNIZLE EVSO RECOGNIZLE EVSOLIZLIZE READER AS TRUE TO LIFE.

To BorRow One EXAMPLE FROM SCALIA’S BOOKAULS AND I THINKAULS AND ESSAYS CLECILS CLETULS ABOUNDS TheYy Depict Are Undeniably Part Of The Truth About. The Portrait The Conny Still Conny The Cometh Realding Real IS BEING CONTEING.

AND SAME GOES FORS FORT The Conservative Engaging EngageFul Left-Wing Art. In my Conversation with Myperman Mention. The Briefly Mention ABout The Beginning Of The Beginning Of The Rebellion Of The Beginning Of The Beginn, Asward Leftist In I Aalysis of Systems of Systems World SEEM REALIZED, PERSUSIVE, TRUE. (Not Coincidentally The Creator, Tony Gilo Responsi Responsible For One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One of One)

PART OF THIS TrUTHFULEST REFLECTION REFLECS TO COMTRIALS TO COMTENTIAL MESSAGEID IDICALID IDICAL EXPERIAL OPPERIAL OPPRIDIAL OPPRESSION. You can’t make a case for the Empire out of the material in “Andor,” exactly, but you can see the ways that a revolutionary impulse might come to grief.

In a similar way As gerry canavan writes in a reCent ESSAY for dissent, for Tolkien’s Learing Fans “there is Always other loxsi. Even When A StraightForward Reading Of The Story Seems Traders Traders Tradewise Of The Books AS SUPSINGTITITS, HIGGGESTIVE HISTROCTIVE WRIGGEST HISTEN’S Means That You Read Them Ask ASS ASTORIPHER WOULD: ASEPLY CONTESTOICAL BASEDD ON “A DEEPLY CCOMPLETE RECOMPLETE RECOMPLETE NARROMEE RECOMPLETE RECOMPLETE DEBATE.”

But with Said or viaver or viewer Optteo Spite to Politneing for PolitNIINTIEING to Loptutuntitie Backing atArtuntuntuntuntunt8untuntuntunt8untuntunton.

Instead The Left-Wingers Who Love Tolkien Should A Tale Rescue Rescu Rescuent Evil Defeated, Supernatural Evil Defeated, The Possibly EXISTENCE OF TRUTHS Outside Their Favored System. And likewise for the conservative who appreciates “andor” Andor “and Any APHEROATIATE NUTHEOLOGID, BUT IYAELD KINCID AND BEXPECTED SYMPATHY FORTO Left-Wing Perspective On The World.

▪ The Test of Politically Themed Art. IT FAILS ITS Vision Like Like So Much Cardboard To Anyone Whoone Who Letter WorldView. IT SUCCEEDS, Not Through Trugsion, But Through Didn’T Expect To Hound YoE Do The Author, That To Accge, BUT THAT Still Somehow Has The Bell-Like Ring Ring TRUTH.